• Car Accidents
  • Truck Accidents
  • Workers' Compensation
  • Wrongful Death
  • Practice Areas
  • About Us
  • Videos
  • Verdicts
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • An Example of How Car Accident Witness Statements Effected a Case

    An Example of How Car Accident Witness Statements Effected a Case

    The impact of witnesses in car accident cases

    Car accidents can be a terrifying experience.

    The aftermath of an accident is always difficult to deal with, but little thought is usually given to the bystanders who have witnessed the automobile accident.

    As car accident attorneys, who have seen our fair share of automobile accidents, we have first-hand knowledge of the dangers still present even after a car accident.

    Because of this, the first thing that should be on your mind after you are involved in a car accident is to assess your injuries and get to safety as quickly as possible.

    After that, there are a handful of things we advise you to do to protect yourself legally like take photos, document the scene, write down what you remember while it is still fresh in your mind, and several other important steps to take after your car accident.

    Regardless of whom you think is at fault, we strongly advise you speak with witnesses to hear their side of the story.

    In some cases, the other person involved in the car accident, who may be the person responsible for the accident, may “charm” witnesses into believing his or her story.

    Because of this, we strongly advise hearing car accident witness statements as soon as possible.

    Related: Commercial Truck Accident Statistics in 2021

    A real-life example of how a witness impacted a car accident victim

    The following story is a true one experienced by a friend of mine involved in a car accident.

    For the sake of privacy, and to make it easier to differentiate between the two drivers, we are going to call him “Jake”.

    Several years ago, Jake was driving in South St. Louis near an intersection. As he began to cross the intersection, the light turned yellow.

    As he was about to make his way through, a truck traveling the opposite direction attempted to speed up and make a left turn; crossing paths with Jake’s vehicle.

    Unfortunately, Jake was unable to avoid colliding with the other man’s vehicle and hit the rear end of his truck at speeds around 40 miles per hour.

    Jake’s airbags were deployed (and actually caught fire) and his car was totaled. He was shaken up but other than a headache, he thankfully had no other serious injuries.

    The other driver was seemingly fine and, by the time Jake was able to get out of his vehicle and make his way to safety, the other passenger had already been speaking with a man standing outside a building around 100 yards away.

    When first responders arrived and began making their car accident police report, the other driver and the “witness” quickly approached the police officer and told them his light turned from a blinking yellow arrow to a green arrow, so he had the right of way, thus Jake had to have ran a red light.

    Jake pleaded his case, but since he was outnumbered and defending himself against a witness with nothing to gain, he was unsure how he would be able to convince the office or insurance agents he was not at fault.

    With little help from his car insurance provider, Jake decided to investigate the scene on his own.

    In doing so, he was able to provide indisputable proof that the accident could not have been his fault. 

    While doing some reconnaissance, Jake noticed that that particular intersection’s lights were on a timer and the only time the arrow turns green is immediately after it is red. It then switches to a blinking yellow arrow.

    In other words, there was no possible way the arrow could have gone from yellow to green. The moral of the story is the other driver was able to implant the idea in the witness’s head that he was not at fault after just a few minutes of talking.

    It is also important to point out that Jake’s insurance provider provided little to no assistance in proving his innocence.

    The witness was certainly not intentionally lying to police or trying to cover for the other man, but he had seen an accident, and since he was standing at a distance too far to reliably say what had happened, he was influenced by the first story he heard and believed it must have been true.

    Related: How is Fault Determined in Car Accident Cases?

    The importance of speaking to witnesses after your car accident

    Now, we want to make it clear that we in no way condone or advise you to attempt to influence a witness into falsely corroborating your claims.

    Speaking to car accident witnesses should simply be to collect information.

    In most cases, someone who claims to have witnessed a car accident is a reliable source of information and they may have seen things you did or may have forgotten about due to the chaos after the accident.

    Speak with a St. Louis car accident lawyer

    If you or a loved one has been injured in a car accident, we strongly advise you to speak with a local personal injury attorney.

    Here at Ortwerth Law, we are personal injury attorneys who help car accident victims in St. Louis, Missouri and the surrounding areas get the compensation they deserve.

    Contact our offices to set up a free car accident consultation.

    Looking to speak to an injury attorney?

    Fill out the form below to schedule a free consultation with Craig


    Ortwerth Law, LLC
    4.9
    Based on 27 reviews
    powered by Google
    tim schmidtim schmid
    20:27 26 Jun 24
    If you need legal representation, Ortwerth LLC is who I recommend. Communication, compassion and professionalism...
    Renee MahnRenee Mahn
    21:55 06 Sep 23
    5 Stars Outstanding!I was always contacted and informed regarding my case. I did not have to go out of my way for anything. The process was very easy for me.Thank you
    Katlyne ThiesKatlyne Thies
    12:14 20 Sep 20
    I’m so grateful that Craig Ortwerth and his office took on my car accident case. Craig was so easy to work with and he quickly replied back to any questions or concerns I had and explained every step to me. I felt such relief knowing I was in good hands and I didn’t have to worry about dealing with the insurance company so I could focus on healing from my accident.
    Christie HessChristie Hess
    04:56 06 Jun 19
    Having Craig work on my case from beginning to end was the best decision I'd ever made! My case went on for 3 1/2 years and during that time i never had to worry about "bothering him or his staff with questions, or their patience in explaining what was going on or what I needed to do. They kept me and everyone involved informed and things went along smoothly! I hope to never have a case like this again, but if I do, there is absolutely NO doubt in my mind as to where I'd go and who I'd have to handle my case!!I highly recommend anyone to at least sit down for a consult. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!! Great Job Craig (& Marcie!!)
    Monica CrenshawMonica Crenshaw
    21:12 03 Jun 19
    Craig was great and did a fantastic job for me. He is very professional and knew how to do his job. Craig is a very friendly, compassionate and understanding person. He answered all my questions and called to see how I was doing. I would recommend Craig to everyone. In my book he is an outstanding attorney.
    D SCD SC
    23:43 26 Nov 18
    Brian McChesney is the BEST divorce lawyer I have ever experienced or come across. He goes out of his way to help, and has the best suggestive advice. I appreciate his integrity, valor, and honesty. I cant even begin to express my gratitude and thankfulness! Wonderful guy!-Laura
    Michael RussellMichael Russell
    02:50 24 Jul 18
    Craig was AWESOME to work with!! If I had a question he had no problem taking my call or returning a call if he was busy. I literally did nothing except sign papers. He did everything for me and made the process of my workmans composition settlement stress free!!! Give Craig a call, I believe he will make you a very happy client like me!!
    js_loader